| The Butterfingers Angel | Ted Moller | |
| Herod the Nut | Paul Johnson | |
| Mary | Molly Riter | |
| Joseph | Mark Trussell | |
| The Donkey | Eli Semotiuk | |
| Man in Grey | Donald Carson | |
| The Tree | Jackie Ravine | |
| Courier | Jason Wells | |
| Village Women/Herod's Concubines | Jolene Michelle Parker Heidi Volf |
|
| One of the Three Kings | Brian Reed | |
| Additional Actors: |
Joe Michel Doug Quast Darren Nebergall Neil Kopplin Rick Wright |